Why the float test isn’t reliable
The float test puts loose strands in water and reads meaning into whether they float or sink. At home, the result can change with product on the surface, trapped air, strand thickness, the water’s surface tension, stirring, and how long you wait. And a loose strand doesn’t tell you whether it came from the root, middle or end. Don’t take one floating or sinking strand as proof of low or high porosity.
If you try it, use several clean strands from parts of your head you can name, and treat the result as a hint only. Don’t buy or drop products because of it. Compare it with how the same areas wet and dry on an ordinary wash day.
Put a strand in the glass
How to do the spray test fairly
Spraying dry hair can show whether droplets stay on top or spread into a section, but styling product and how dense the section is strongly affect what you see. A mist may land on the outer layer without reaching the strands underneath. Oils, gels and leave-ins can change how water sits on the surface. The test is more useful after a normal wash, on separated sections with similar amounts of hair.
Note how long droplets stay and whether roots and ends differ. Don’t rely on it if the result changes when you separate the section or after you wash out product.
Watch how your hair wets and dries over a few washes
On similar wash days, note how long clean sections take to get fully wet under running water. After the wash, compare similar sections with similar airflow and product amounts. Research shows that water changes the cuticle and fiber, but timing it in your bathroom isn’t a lab measurement. It becomes useful when you see the same thing wash after wash.
Something that happens in the same place every time tells you more than a one-off. If it goes away after you clarify, leftover product was probably the cause. If new growth and processed ends behave differently, care for each section differently rather than giving your whole head one label.
Notice how it feels after each change
Feeling rough, coated, tangled or weighed down by product can point to a routine problem, but none of those feelings is unique to porosity. Note when it happens: before washing, after rinsing conditioner, after leave-in, or after your style dries. That timing points to the step worth changing.
If the coated feeling shows up only after several leave-in layers, drop one or use less of it. If detangling gets easier or harder when you use a mask instead of conditioner, write that down. Stick to what your routine did, rather than guessing at a condition you can’t see.
Write down how sure you are
Use “probably low,” “probably high,” “mixed” or “not sure,” and write your reasons next to it. Only call it sure when the same thing happens across several similar washes. Pick mixed when roots and ends differ. Pick not sure when leftover product, recent color or chemical treatment, or changing conditions could explain what you saw just as well.
Keep the next change small: wet more thoroughly, drop one optional layer, change where conditioner goes, or do a reset wash if you can see buildup. Keep the rest of your routine the same so you can tell what worked.
Test your routine, not the label’s promises
Compare products that do the same job and follow each bottle’s directions. Measure how much you use when possible. Our ingredient comparison can help you narrow the choices; your own wash-day result helps you decide which to keep.
Questions before your next wash
What if I am still unsure what to change?
Keep the steps that work, change one thing at a time and follow your product’s directions. A guide can’t tell you what’s causing a scalp or hair problem.
Updated · The sources for this guide are on our Sources page. Report a changed detail.